Reservation
Visit Us
About
Welcome to Colchester Pizza Restaurant, a hidden gem located at 59 Lebanon Ave, Colchester, CT, where culinary tradition and modern flavor intersect to create a memorable dining experience. This charming eatery boasts a cozy, colonial-inspired ambiance, making it the ideal spot for families and friends to gather over great food. With a phone call away at +1 860-537-2653, you'll find it both welcoming and convenient.
Colchester Pizza Restaurant excels in crafting artisanal pizzas that have captured the hearts—and appetites—of locals. Customers rave about the unique flavor profiles of their pizzas, particularly the spaghetti and meatball pizza, a delightful blend that intrigues the palate while showcasing the restaurant's creativity. The standout feature? A perfectly prepared pizza dough that has received high praise, leaving guests hungry for more with every bite! As one loyal fan puts it, “I would eat it alone; it's so good!”
But pizza is only the tip of the iceberg here. The menu also boasts a selection of baked Italian dinners, including their Four Cheese Lasagna and Stuffed Jumbo Shells, each priced affordably at US$16.49. These dishes are a testament to the restaurant's commitment to quality, with house-made sauces that diners can't help but rave about. One satisfied customer noted, “The dinners, such as lasagna and stuffed shells, are excellent!”
For those who appreciate a hearty meal, their Calzones and Strombolis are popular choices, featuring rich fillings accompanied by savory pizza sauce. The Calzone with Pizza Sauce is a must-try at US$14.99, making it a fulfilling option for any pizza lover.
Parking is easy, and the overall experience is incredibly inviting, as echoed by guest Jason Evans, who enjoyed both the atmosphere and the service. Colchester Pizza Restaurant isn’t just about excellent food; it’s about community and comfort, providing a small-town charm that makes every visit special. With a commitment to quality and a menu filled with diverse options, this restaurant is worth a visit for pizza aficionados and Italian food lovers alike. So why not bring your family or friends and indulge in the delectable offerings that await you?
“ I did a pickup there for the first time and the two people working were very nice and it's cozy in there! Didn't expect the style but it kind of older style like a small colonial room to dine in. Very cool. And parking was easy. Pizza is my second favorite so far. I loved it ”
“ The dinners, such as lasagna, stuffed shells, are excellent! Their sauce, which you can also purchase separately, is pretty awesome, too! ”
“ Their amazing pizzas are unique and definitely leave you craving for more! I think the secret is in their flavorful pizza dough! I would eat it alone; it's so good! ”
“ I stopped in here with my family after a long 5 mile hike the other day. I was genuinely blown away by the pizza and customer service. I am not usually one to write reviews, but hopefully someone looking for a pizza and unsure where to go gives this place a shot. We saw a pizza called the spagetti&meatball pizza and while odd it was delicious and will become a must order next time we go. ”
“ Had the best pizza I’ve ever gotten from Colchester Pizza tonight. The crust was crisp and it wasn’t so greasy that I couldn’t pick up a slice to eat it. I have liked Colchester Pizza for a long time having lived here for 30 years, but tonight was fantastic. If you like Greek style pizza, this is the place! ”
“ I am a New Haven style pizza purest. Although Colchester Pizza is not that style, it is amongst the best pizzas I have had. Certainly the best in town. The dough is very good, and the pie is always cooked to perfection! Duane and the crew are awesome! If you haven’t been there, go! You will be happy you did. ”
“ Best pizza in town! Great burgers Edit:9 Now under new ownership! It took a bit for them to get in the groove, but now its still great! Prices like everything have gone way up. So be aware of that. ”
“ Pizza was delicious! Staff was friendly! No other information needed :) ”